Transcript 0:01 Hello, founders and investors. Welcome back to Next Round Ready. I'm your host, Chris. Today, we have special guest, Kevin Raper from Venture Catalyst. Kevin, welcome to the show. Thank you, Chris. 0:12 So I always like to start off with the foundation of things. What got you to the venture capital world? Like, how did you get here? It's a long story. You got a few minutes? Let's do it. Let's do it. Okay. 0:25 I started off, uh, go all the way back, designing for theater. I was very successful in that. I won a big award at the Kennedy Center in undergraduate school, and that kinda opened the whole world up to me design-wise. 0:39 I worked in Prague, London, Berlin, Toronto, Las Vegas for a while. That quickly led into TV and film, and that was kind of my hundred plus hours a week up until COVID. Uh, the world shut down. 0:53 I no longer had that income and that validation and those thirty million people seeing what I did every week, and, uh, really wasn't sure why I was living, why I was doing what I was doing, and it was this whole existential moment. 1:05 At that time period, my wife was working for a startup that did post-harvest solutions for cannabis in New York. 1:13 I invested about a hundred and fifty thousand into that company and had quite the inferiority, this imposter syndrome, and was just trying to learn as fast as I could. 1:24 I kinda jumped in with some go-to-market, bringing my design experience from film and commercials and TV, and learned a lot, and I don't know, felt like I was always two steps behind. Um, 1:37 a year or so later, we had the writers strike and shut down again for nine and a half months. I think I had four or five more friends die at that point. Uh, I went to detox. 1:47 I got sober and, uh, really started to reexamine what I wanted out of my life and, uh, it ended up being working with, uh, startups and founders and solving problems and investing in people. 2:01 I feel like at pre-seed it's the people who are gonna make or break it. Uh, they may pivot three times. YouTube was a dating app. Right. Places pivot. 2:10 But, um, I've just really had this amazing journey since then, and I think now I have seventeen companies I've angel invested in. I've started a fund. We're working on a venture studio and a foundation. 2:24 Um, I don't know, it's just the most amazing ride ever. I'm really grateful for where we are now and even how I got here, as difficult as it was for a while. That's how I got here now. That is interesting. So 2:37 how do you find the companies that you invest in? You said you're nearing twenty. How do you find the companies you wanna put money into? Okay. Um, at this point in my life, they find me. 2:49 I feel like I get to do one or two founder calls every day pretty much. When I was starting to put together Venture Catalyst stuff, my partner said, "You're really not participating on LinkedIn." 3:01 And I'd always thought of LinkedIn as like Facebook for business folks, so I never was involved. I started doing one or two nice posts about other people every week. 3:11 And instead of focusing on me and what I was doing, talking about others, and that really just build and build and build and build and build exponentially. And yeah, that was kinda the basis of it. 3:21 A lot of deal flow now. I'm also involved in like Hustle Fund and some other VC that I advise for, and I don't know, always do good, uh, and you'll do well by doing good, I think, in the long run. 3:34 Yeah, I've heard about Hustle Fund as like one of the best places for the early stage angel investors who are like starting out, who are trying to get their feet wet and really understand how the process works and get in on some deals. 3:47 And do you also know Play Money? Let's Play Money and Scroobius? I've heard of Scroobius. Okay. Scroobius is Allison. We connected via LinkedIn, and, uh, she's really educating people that they can be angels. 4:01 Everyone's so nervous to start, and you just kinda have to jump in and start swimming, you know? Right. I totally agree. You can't- Get a little skin in the game. 4:10 Yeah, you, you can't hold yourself back too long because then you're just missing out on opportunity, and it's just constant. 4:16 And then once you put that angel investor and your name on socials, that right there alone is gonna inspire some deal flow, just putting it in your name. 4:23 So what's one of the things that really differents- differentiates you and your fund and what you're doing in the investor space? 4:32 Right now there's an interesting product that a friend of mine, Randall Andrews, and I are building. We call it The Fulcrum. 4:40 And I started working with more and more, uh, like leadership assessment tools, uh, this past year in helping to determine how founders are going to act and then how f- co-founders might interact together. 4:52 I see a lot of times small teams sort of implode because they don't have great emotional intelligence or great communication skills. 5:00 So we started with stuff like the Myers-Brigg Personality Sorter and the DiSC assessment, and then we brought in some emotional intelligence assessments, one called the Failure Index, and we've been building one I'm calling the Grit Assessment for a while now. 5:15 And with the use of AI, I can start to compound these things together. 5:20 And then the way I ran into Randall, Randall was work- working on building a tool to help, uh, neurodivergent individuals understand information better, so it would translate it into the way they processed information. 5:32 So if you're detail-oriented, it would be detail to big picture or vice versa. Um, and I told him his app didn't work for me. A lot of times when he had A or B, I wanted both or neither. 5:42 And he came back a week later, and he said, "I built you your own app." [laughs] So I started taking all the other leadership assessment tools and putting them through that, and it's been phenomenal tool so far. 5:53 So we built that, and then we're sort of doing a modular version where you can take the different founders and put them together in the same system and see how they... 6:03 their strengths and weaknesses play off of one another. 6:06 And then this week, we've been building a chat bot that uses all of that to help translate and interpret an API to your calendar to sorta see like, or your Slack-You're being really terse this week. 6:16 Maybe, you know, we need to work on some stuff. So that kind of tool that's just really founder-focused is really where I'm loving being right now. The other stuff we can solve. That's something that's hard to solve. Oh. 6:29 You can teach empathetic people to be doctors, but it's hard to teach doctors to be empathetic- Mm... if that makes any sense. 6:37 That's a really interesting breakdown, 'cause I find that the founder is the most important thing that an investor is looking at, even outside- In my opinion... of the team. Yeah. Yeah. So- And so- Especially early on... 6:48 what are, like, three traits that you look for in a founder then, that, like, if you see these three things, you're for sure gonna want to invest with them or work with them long term? Okay. 6:57 So there's this one that's sort of a paradox. It's very strong convictions loosely held. 7:03 You've really gotta go out into life thinking, like, you're confident in your own ability, and at the same point, as soon as you learn something, you have to be able to adapt to what you've learned and to change your perception of the world. 7:15 You can't wait for the whole world to come to where you want it to be. You need to go to where the world is, basically. 7:22 So for a while, this is gonna sound bad to you guys, tech bro type founders I had a hard time dealing with, but a lot of female founders, a lot of minorities, a lot of immigrant founders, they already came through life with that, "How do I observe and adapt to work in this world that's not necessarily built for me?" 7:40 So I felt like they were much more agile as we overcame obstacles and went forward. They had that resilience and that, I don't know, that grit. So I, I would say that's the biggest thing. 7:51 I guess I kinda combined three things all into one. That makes sense. Humility goes with it. 7:56 Humility is always interesting, because from my perspective, if you play it a little too humble and you're too small, then you lose the respect in the room. You know what I mean? Humility is knowing your place. 8:07 It's not making yourself small. If your place is as a CEO, then it's knowing your place is as a CEO. And it's... Okay, okay. This is interesting. It's just being right-sized. 8:16 So what's one of the experiences you've had investing that really has shaped your thesis to focus so much on the founders? I don't know where I'd start with that. I'm unsure where to start with that. 8:26 Can we come back to that one? Let me kinda elaborate a little bit on the question, 'cause I think- Okay... 8:32 when I hear somebody like you that's so focused on the founder specifically, it's interesting, because I've talked to investors who focus more on the team overall- Yep... or even product- Yep... 8:43 versus the founder, you know- Well-... where they're not as d- as deep on that... everybody has the product. The product still has to work, but I feel like if I just focus... I guess that's the... 8:56 Where I differentiate is I want those overlooked founders who I think are gonna... I don't know, they're the underdogs that are gonna win. 9:04 But I don't know, there's a lot of same product out there, and I've been having this argument about moat recently that, I don't know, I don't think moats are always the way that VC perceive them. 9:16 I think if you have enough money and enough smart people in the room, you can always overcome that moat, even if it's IP. You know what I mean? 9:22 Like, I'll go fight a patent later, but I don't know, the people, like, that's the hardest part. So, and if they're coachable. 9:29 Like, I've got this one company, uh, that used to be called VoicePath, and we've pivoted a few times, but there's that resilience and that learning and, I don't know. 9:39 And I've also got big, like, Anthropic and stuff like that. That's just about money. That's not about [laughs] the people anymore. [laughs] There, there's my... Can you see the board over there? I can see it, yeah. 9:51 Yeah, that's all, and then these are all the companies, or a lot of the companies I advise on. Okay. Okay, I got another good question for you. 9:58 So if the founder and focusing on h- them and who they are and the humility, the grit is important to you, what are three things that really deter you from working with a founder? 10:08 Like, three things you could see on their social post or in an email or in a phone conversation where you're just like, "I don't wanna work with this person." Um, I guess when they don't listen 10:20 or we don't have a, a conversation. But even then, I try and give them the benefit of the doubt to start and do that first phone call regardless because, I don't know, I've been so surprised. 10:31 I feel like a lot of the companies I work with now are not ones I would've gone looking for. One of the ones in legal tech, he was sitting next to us at a coffee shop while I was coaching another founder on a pitch. Wow. 10:42 And I went out, 'cause I was still smoking at the time. I went out to have a cigarette, and he came out and he said, "Can I talk to you about what you're telling that guy?" 10:49 And I ended up working with the guy next to us who wasn't part of the meeting at all. So just be open, like, I don't know. 10:56 At a VC thing, uh, north of here, it's the guy I met in the stairwell who I ended up working with, not the person I went to see at the conference. 11:05 So it's, it's always those serendipitous connections that end up being more... I don't know. They're little godwinks. That's a good point. 11:13 I think friendliness as a founder is kind of underrated, because a lot of founders I know now have a ton of partnerships and a ton of relationships to help their company grow. 11:23 Or you being friendly is gonna help you hire the right team members and really grow the company. 11:28 So, like, that friendly trait is kind of, like, a top five thing you have to have, and it kinda plays into being coachable as well. So I, I, this is another question. 11:37 I love asking people like you this question, people with high conviction. When you're 50/50 on an investment, when you're trying to decide if you wanna go with this or not, what's the thing that tips the scale for you? 11:48 That's gonna be a weird one. So I prefer before I even hear a pitch, I wanna have all the information up front. 11:56 I've built my own GPTs for about a year now with some of my principles, things I've learned, books that I really admire, other documents I've written, and I build a GPT. 12:06 And then in that GPT, I put everything I can find about that company, everything from their deck. 12:12 I do some competitive landscape, and then-As my brain goes throughout the day, just keep throwing it in the GPT, and it keeps me an updated investor brief based on how I like to consume it. 12:24 So then when I get to that presentation, I'm not digesting information for the first time. I can sort of be present with them and, I don't know, kind of go where that takes me. 12:34 And it really allows me to be more a part of that conversation. But I'll say at the end of the day, it's gonna end up being my gut. It's not my head always. Like, I don't know, I kinda feel it down here nowadays. 12:45 But I think if you don't do all of that research and, I don't know, mental investment beforehand, you can't go with your gut [laughs]. I 100% agree. 12:54 I think the gut instinct that we all have is something that, it's a natural thing we have, but you kinda have to feed it a little bit with the information and the exercising you do so that you can listen to it more. 13:06 It l- it's like it gets louder the more you feed it. Whether, w- whereas if you don't feed it, you can't really hear it. 13:13 Even if it's talking to you, could be yelling at you, you can't hear it because you don't really feed that system inside of you enough. You know what I mean? I totally agree. 13:22 If I do the hard work all day, some of my best thoughts are in that spot between awake and asleep, where you're half dreaming and your brain gets the rest of the work done. Yes. 13:31 But if you didn't do all that work all day, you don't get to that liminal space. Yes. I, I, okay, I, I gotta ask you about your books now, 'cause I think- Okay... 13:39 the books are kind of underrated in, in, in the investment space. I, I'm literally reading Venture Deals again myself right now. 13:47 And I go and get all the books, and some, some need to be read, and I think some other books need to be studied. Some books are so good you have to read it, take notes, read it again- Yep... 13:57 and then read it a third time to really, like, grasp the concept, you know? And- Is that Venture Deals fourth edition that Brad Feld was co-author on? Yes. 14:07 Yeah, that's a 10 times read 'cause [laughs] there's something- Yes... on page 98 you'll forget. Yeah. Um, but another great one- Hmm. Give First... that's another Brad book as well, and I, I kinda live by this. 14:21 So Give First, if people don't have video. Yeah, I'll put it in the show notes for everybody out there listening. So w- what's an- another two or three books that you just kinda like, you've studied over the years? 14:30 Well, they're not always gonna be about investing. I think the, the best investors, the best founders are people who can learn something in one situation and apply it in another situation. 14:41 I sit on some, like, due diligence investor committee type things every week, and we have a lot of experts in there. 14:48 And I feel like those guys are really good in their bucket, and when you take them out of their bucket of knowledge, they don't know what to do. Yeah. 14:53 And the people I wanna work with can take this bucket of knowledge over here, apply it in a novel situation, and that's how we're gonna win and get new things invented in this world, new solutions. You know what I mean? 15:05 I can learn how a door functions and go and apply it in another [laughs] situation down the road. So it's not always have to be an investing book. It can be a book about, 15:15 I don't know, how Hemingway wrote and how all the things he didn't say, 89% of it was stuff that he developed and never said out loud, and it made the rest of those couple of words work so much harder. I don't know. 15:28 Know your market- I'm with you... know everything. I like to read the sci-fi books. Those kind of- Yeah... I don't know why. They connect the dots for me. When I'm not thinking too deeply about business- Yep... 15:38 I can make progress faster. Okay. Neal Stephenson, is he a, a guy of yours? Neal Stephenson. Did you read The Baroque Cycle? He has a lot of more popular ones, and that one's like thousands of pages. 15:50 But there's this one part in it where it's the develop- the development of the modern banking system and writing checks from the Netherlands. Instead of sending gold on a boat to London, they're using paper checks. 16:02 [laughs] So I don't know, things like that where I'm like, "Brilliant." Or the history of the Mongolians and how they're conquering different cultures and not inventing anything but saying, "Hey, abacus. 16:12 That would be good over here. Hey, credit. That would be easier than moving cows across the continent. We'll just take certificates that are worth cows." Like all of these- Yeah... things, you're like, "Holy shit." Yeah. 16:22 The best way they ever conquered a city, in my opinion, one of the coolest ones. So Chinggis Khan comes to this city, and they says, "We'll leave you alone if you give us all your cat." And they're like, "Okay." 16:33 So they give them all the cats, and they tie a long string to their tail. They put a ball of felt on the end, like horsehair dipped in oil. 16:41 They light it on fire, and they let all the cats go, and they conquered a whole city without ever going inside. All the cats went home, climbed in the house, and burned the houses down. I mean, that's brilliant. Yeah. 16:52 It, and that, uh, that's why I try not to get too deep into business sometimes because- Yeah... you kinda gotta step out, like, and see it from a bird's-eye view. 17:01 And reading other types of information or, my thing too is documentaries, just weird random stuff on YouTube. 17:08 It just makes you see things differently and think differently, and then when you go back to the table, you're like, "Okay, I got this new concept," and then you can progress. 17:15 Like, I've been doing that with the content in the podcast space here, like with this show specifically. I have some incredible things planned, and i- it's already working out, so this has been really, really fun. 17:25 We turned this into a complete, like, nerd session. Like, we're going off track [laughs] completely. I'm sorry. Okay. People will enjoy it. They get to know the people. Right, right. Okay. I got, I got a couple more. 17:34 A couple more. So what does your typical investment look like? You know, are you s- focused on specific industries? Is there a specific check size you go for? As an angel or in the fund we're building? 17:44 You wanna do angel? As an angel, yeah. Okay. Uh, my typical check size, smallest are usually 10, 15K. Largest so far has been 150K. I like to have enough... Well, I like to have pro rata rights. 17:57 I like to be able to play along as we go if we win. I don't know. I guess, is that a good start with that? That's perfect. 18:03 And then even when I can't or don't agree money-wise, I've often stayed on as an advisor and given my perspective on things and how to succeed better. And sometimes that's been a lot more valuable. 18:16 If I can take, like-$4 million valuation and be a $40 million valuation in a few months. That's a lot better than if I put in my extra $50,000 right now. So stuff like that has been really interesting. 18:28 One of the companies I'm working with right now that I thought was absolutely dead for almost a year is a social media app that's relaunching soon. Really? And, uh, maybe we, we should talk about it offline. Oh, offline. 18:41 Offline. We'll see. Okay. No, no, you don't have to put it in there. We don't have to put it in there. [laughs] Okay. Okay, okay. That's... 18:45 And I love asking that question because a lot of founders I talk to, they don't understand the, I guess, the gap in terms of what angel checks look like all the time. They always think it's either a million or nothing. 18:58 And it's like, no, you can work with some angels at the 50 level, at 100. It just depends on the angels you're talking to. Yeah. That's why you need to talk to more angels. 19:07 I'm leading an SPV right now for a female founder who's in the death tech space. She does trusts and estate planning as a employee benefit. 19:17 And what I'm doing with that one is I'm basically rallying the troops on play money and saying, "Hey, let's all put in small 1,000 to $5,000 checks to help close this round." So- Hmm... that works as well. 19:32 It's very much possible. And you get investor updates, and you're a player, and now you start learning. And once you start learning, you'll make another one and another one and another one, and yeah. I love it, man. 19:43 I love it. 19:44 I, I think the angel side is super interesting to me because th- there are rules to it, but I also think if you're a founder, there's a lot more freedom within the angel space if you have the right angel investors that you're working with. 19:57 It's just not as, as strict and strenuous as the VC world is all the time. And the people you put on your cap table, I think the founder should interview the investor as much as the investor should screen the founder. 20:12 Like, there are people you do not want on your cap table. Um, yeah, all of that. It's a marriage forever. It's a marriage till you exit. Hmm. 20:21 Man, okay, this has been an incredible conversation, but my last question I, I gotta ask my investors all the time is what's that one thing you're looking for in a company you're gonna invest in? 20:31 Something that is just a non-negotiable. It could be with the founder, the team, product, anything. What is that one just mandatory thing that has to be there for you? 20:40 Okay, I'm gonna make it into two, 'cause one, it does have to look to me like it's financially viable and we're gonna win. And it doesn't have to be a 100x win, but I do like a 30x win. 20:49 But for me these days, it has to spark my curiosity and my imagination and make me excited. If it doesn't make me excited, I don't wanna play this game. I'll just go and invest in my favorite mutual fund. 21:02 [laughs] True, yeah. I could do that through Vanguard. So it's gotta be a lot of fun. 21:07 One of the ones right now I'm doing, they're underwriting loans for small business owners, underserved groups, usually minorities, and usually it's the 5 to $50,000, uh, range that banks don't really wanna touch. 21:19 They spend the same amount underwriting a 1,000 as a 500,000. And also just trying to figure out, like, code... Do you know code switching? Yeah. 21:28 Okay, so we're gonna use a different vocabulary with a small business owner who may not have finished high school or may not have gone to an Ivy League college. 21:35 But then w- the loan fund people are very conservative, and we use a different language in getting that money to give out loans. And then the dilutive 21:45 equity, the people who are helping us scale this underwriting platform, that's a whole different language we need. 21:50 So we have three different languages and three audiences we're speaking to, and we're trying to build an underwriting system that doesn't use credit scores. How do we say if someone is trustworthy without using that? 22:01 What kind of behavioral science? And what got me interested, I said to her the first day, I said, "Do you think just giving them that loan makes them more trustworthy?" Is that... You know what I'm saying? Yeah. 22:11 Like, the fact that I gave you trust makes you more trustworthy. And I was like, "All right. I really wanna play with this one." So- That's super interesting... we've been hardcore for two months now, but it's amazing. 22:20 Wow, that's an interesting company. I, I gotta say, I love those kind of companies too that aren't just another CRM, another Notion. Like, it's very, very different and specific to solving a problem that actually exists. 22:34 Like I've... In AI space, I get founders reaching out to me every day, and it's always something, something AI. 22:40 But I'm like, "Where's the, the thing, this problem you're really solving that actually is gonna help people, instead of you just throwing AI out there?" 22:47 It sounds really good, but that sounds really, really helpful to the world. I guess I'm an impact investor this past year or two. Yeah. Love that. We have to be doing good to do well. I don't wanna do it the other way. 23:00 Amazing, man. This has been a great conversation. Kevin, do you want founders from the show to reach out to you possibly? Yeah. I always like meeting new people. All right. 23:09 I'll make sure I link you up in the, your website in the show notes, your LinkedIn and everything like that. Thank you for being such an incredible guest. Thank you, Chris